The Bowles spinsters were said to be tough old publicans. The Irish sisters were noted for their pluck, and for not taking a backward step when challenged. They owned and operated the long-gone Atlas Hotel, on the Brisbane docks for over 40 years, and became infamous for litigation. They were familiar faces in the Brisbane courts and greater fodder for newspapers of the time.
The sisters, Margaret Julia and Mary Ann Bowles became hosts of the Kings Hotel at the corner of Stanley and Russell Streets South Brisbane in 1907. Margaret at the age of 27 was granted the transfer of the license of the old wharfies’ pub from Edward Turner Mead in March of that year. The following year she the changed the name of the pub from the Kings to the Atlas, and there she remained as one of Brisbane’s longest serving publicans for 44 years until her death at the age of 88 in 1951.
The sprightly old landlady kept a tight rein on the operation of her pub, and it was reported that her walking stick was often used threatingly as a deterent to unruly behaviour.
Truth (Brisbane, Queensland), Sunday 28 October 1951:
ON Monday last, in Melbourne, the High Court of Australia gave a decision, against Miss Margaret Julia Bowles, well known hotel-keeper of South Brisbane; on Tuesday, Miss Bowles was dead! The court judgement and her death, climaxed a 90 years-long life that had had more than the average in court experiences; for, from the time she was a young girl in Ireland, Margaret Bowles seemed fated to have to do with evictions, and court actions, and bailiffs and fights, and such exciting episodes as most of us miss in plodding our humdrum way through life.
90 YEARS OF FIGHT!
The age-long feud between landlord and tenant played no small part in the life of 90-year-old Miss Bowles, who, incidentally, was a member of one of Queensland’s best-known pioneer families and for nearly 40 years owner and licensee of the historic South Brisbane land-mark, the Atlas Hotel, in Stanley-street. In her youth, which she spent in the County Galway, Ireland, Miss Bowles – and other members of her family – were cast in the unfortunate role of tenants, and, in those days, she and other occupants of her home were forced to bar their windows to prevent bailiffs evicting them on to the street when they ran a’foul of the hated landlord.
Years later, after migrating to Queensland, she and a sister, Mary Ann Bowles, bought the Atlas Hotel, part of which was let to a man named William Taylor Anderson.
In 1948 Miss Bowles became involved in another landlord-and-tenant fight – only this time she was the landlord! Anderson was the tenant. After various appeals, the High Court of Australia gave a verdict in favor of Miss Bowles. And then the old lady commenced another action for damages against Anderson. This, too, went to the High Court of Australia, and its decision, last Monday, was against Miss Bowles – only 24 hours before she died in Brisbane.
It was pointed out that the cost of fighting such a case would be far in excess of the amount of approximately £500 damages at stake, but Miss Bowles, revealing true Irish stubbornness, fought It to the bitter end, and, on her ‘form’ throughout her life, she
probably would have insisted on appealing to the Privy Council from the High Court’s adverse judgment. The old lady showed typical Irish temper, too, during Summons Court proceedings, when she was asked whether it was true that she was worth £150,000, and owned any property other than the Atlas Hotel. “What has it got to do with you, what I am worth?” she snapped at counsel withering him with 90-year-old scorn. “You won’t have to pay any of my debts. I refuse to tell you how much I have got.”
Miss Margaret Julia Bowles came to Australia in the late 1890s, going first to Quilpie, and then to Charleville. Her uncle was a well-known Western Queensland pioneer, and founder in this State, of the wealthy, stations owning Tully family. About 1903 she and her sister came to Brisbane, on their way back to Ireland. They stayed at the South Glen Boarding House, in South Brisbane; but when they discovered the lease of the boarding house was for sale, they took it over and cancelled their trip to Ireland. A few years later they bought the freehold. Then, in 1912, the lease of the nearby Atlas Hotel became vacant; and the two sisters took it over, also. Two years later, they bought the freehold of this property, too. They made two trips to Ireland after that, and except for these brief periods and for one year during wartime, when they gave the lease to a Mrs. Graham, the two sisters conducted the hotel, from 1914. The other sister died in 1947. Unusual incident in the early life of the late Miss Bowles is related by a family friend and business associate. He says Miss Bowles recounted to him how on one occasion in Ireland, the constabulary and bailiffs had gone along to evict her and other members of her family. She and the other tenants, however, lined up and sang, ‘God Save Ireland!’ and it was not long before the bailiffs joined in! That broke the ice, and the officers turned around and went home without evicting the family. It meant the sack for all of them.
He adds that as she and barrister Vince Fogarty left the Brisbane Summons Court after one of her many legal actions, in Brisbane, he commiserated with her on her ordeal in undergoing such a lengthy cross-examination. “She turned and said ‘Don’t worry about me, I was the chief witness in a really important action, long before either of you was born. It was back in Ireland — a murder case — and I was the chief witness. It was my poor brother Henry. He was a kind boy, as good and kind a boy as ever came out of Ireland, but he got into a bit of trouble once, when he shot a bailiff.” Her friend added that the old lady had told him she came from the County Galway, in Ireland – the centre of the Land League troubles. In those days, tenants were being asked to pay impossible rents, and when they could not pay, they were evicted forcibly. Thousands were thrown out of their homes in this fashion, and tenants banded together behind barred doors and windows, using pitchforks and other weapons to resist bailiffs. Miss Bowles told many graphic stories of these stirring times.
The practice of such evictions is described in “The Writings of James Fintan Lalor” as “the cruellest tyranny that ever yet held its vulture clutch over the body and soul of a country,” and “tyranny in its widest scope and worst shape.” And, In the midst of such evictions, Miss Bowles and her family did not escape, this friend said the old lady often told him. She and other members of her family were put out of their homes on one occasion, and one member was lifted out through the roof, on a stretcher. He said Miss Bowles had shown him a picture of this incident.
Truth (Brisbane, Queensland), Sunday 14 September 1952:
TWO CAME FROM OTHER LANDS TO FIGHT WILL
Courts “Followed” Her Beyond The Grave
RIGHT from the time she was a young girl in Ireland, until her death in Brisbane at the age of 88, court actions played a major part in the life of MISS MARGARET JULIA BOWLES, former licensee of the Atlas Hotel, South Brisbane.
She was forever in and out of Brisbane courts, and, with typical Irish stubbornness, she pursued one particular litigation in which she was involved through the Supreme Court, the Full Court of Queensland, and, finally, the High Court of Australia. She died the day after the High Court gave its decision, in October last year. But — even that was not the end of court actions for ‘Maggie’ Bowles! Although she is not in the courtroom, a case which commenced in Brisbane Supreme Court last week and is still proceeding pivots on the late Miss Bowles and her mental state in the few months prior to her demise — not forgetting, of course, her will, and the £45,000 estate she left. Two of her brothers had disputed certain aspects of the four codicils she made to her last, will, probate. In solemn form of which had been sought by solicitor Charles Seymour, an executor and personal friend of deceased. One brother, Ambrose Bowles, has come from New York for the case, and the other, Joseph Patrick, has made the trip from Ireland. They are the only surviving brothers of the once-large family. The case commenced on Wednesday, before Mr. Justice Mansfield, S.PJ., and a jury of four, after lengthy attempts at settlement had proved fruitless. After only a few hours’ evidence, His Honor suggested that another attempt should be made to have the matter decided amicably between the parties. On Friday morning Judge Mansfield again ad-dressed counsel and suggested ways and means that might prevent a long,
drawn-out and costly hearing developing. He told counsel that the jury should first be dispensed with, because, in his opinion, it would only increase the length and cost of the hearing to have one, and he suggested that the parties should compromise. Even ‘Maggie’ Bowles herself had, before her death, shown ‘almost horror,’ when she knew her money was being used in expensive litigation during previous long cases, His Honor pointed out. Counsel then retired for a few minutes, and later announced that the jury would be dispensed with. Ambrose Bowles and the plaintiff, Charles Seymour, also retired from the action. One of the original defendants, Peter Augustin McLaughlin, was then given leave to withdraw his defence, and to become plaintiff in the action. Joseph Bowles thus became the only defendant. When the court adjourned on Friday afternoon until to-morrow morning, McLaughlin was in the position of seeking probate of Miss Bowles’s will, and the first codicil. He also sought as much of the second, third, and fourth codicils as the court might deem fit. Joseph Bowles is opposing probate of the four codicils.